Trying to pay for e-file and getting "We are sorry, we are having trouble authorizing your credit card. Please verify your billing address, card number and CVV and try again."

I am trying to e-file via the downloaded Turbo Tax program (through a popup page) and am getting the following error every time I try to pay the fee: "We are sorry, we are having trouble authorizing your credit card. Please verify your billing address, card number and CVV and try again."

 

Before anyone asks...

-I'm using the correct home address (that matches what the banks have)

-I tried other credit cards + debit card

-I tried logging in with account, as guest