Should I pay 40% tax when my effective tax rate is 13.8%?
Sign Up

Why sign in to the Community?

  • Submit a question
  • Check your notifications
or and start working on your taxes
Announcements
TurboTax has you covered during Covid. Get the latest second stimulus info here.
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
New Member

Should I pay 40% tax when my effective tax rate is 13.8%?

I have filed my tax return, and got my refund. Then I realized that although my effective tax rate is 13.8%, I pay 40% , I tested this by minus 100 from my income, and I got $40.19 more refund back.
3 Replies
New Member

Should I pay 40% tax when my effective tax rate is 13.8%?

You are conflating the concepts of "marginal tax rate" and "effective tax rate."

In the US, we have a federal income tax and state income taxes, that are based on the idea of a "progressive tax," that is, the more you earn, the higher your marginal tax rate. The lowest tier of income is taxed at a low rate. The next higher tier of income is taxed at a slightly higher rate. At each step of income, the tax rate becomes higher. You proved this to yourself, when you found that the "last" $100 that you earned was taxed at 40%.

Now, if you calculate a weighted average of the tax rates paid on each step of your income, that is you effective tax rate.

So, while you paid 40% tax on the last or highest increment of your income, the average tax rate on all of the dollars you earned is 13.8%.

Level 15

Should I pay 40% tax when my effective tax rate is 13.8%?

You are asking from TT Self-Employed. Be aware that your SE profit is subject to an additional approx. 15% SE tax, besides the regular income tax.  Also, any increase in income can reduce some deductions and/or credits.
New Member

Should I pay 40% tax when my effective tax rate is 13.8%?

What does TT Self-Employed mean? Turbo Tax Self-Employed?
Dynamic Ads
v
Privacy Settings