After filing 19's W2,my return is less than 18's return, when I made more, and paid more in taxes this past year vs 2018. I made no changes from last year. Why is that?

vash886 · ‎January 16, 2020

DawnC · ‎January 16, 2020

Although tax law changes lowered the rates for five of seven tax brackets, your refund may not be as big as you expected because, proportionately, less income tax was taken out of your paychecks throughout the year. If you didn't update your W-4 for 2019 or 2018 (most people didn't), it’s highly possible this is why your refund isn’t as large as you expected. We've got some other possible reasons for a year-over-year refund decrease, see below.

Changes in your income or tax rate
State and local income tax deduction changes
Losing certain credits or deductions
Not updating your W-4
You had income from Self-Employment
You deferred less income into your Employer-Sponsored Retirement Plan or Flexible Savings Plan
You deleted a dependent or one of your dependents turned 17

The easiest way to determine what happened is to compare this year's return to the previous year's return. Also, double check your data entry to ensure all numbers from your tax documents were entered correctly.

Tip: If your refund is wildly off, you may have mistyped a dollar amount somewhere. An extra digit here, a missing number there, even a misplaced decimal point can have an eye-popping (but easily correctable) effect on your refund.

Video - Why did my refund go down compared to last year's?

Related Information:

**Say "Thanks" by clicking the thumb icon in a post
**Mark the post that answers your question by clicking on "Mark as Best Answer"

View solution in original post

Critter · ‎January 16, 2020

OK ... you may have not "made any changes" but there are always differences from year to year. Review your 2018 & 2019 returns side by side to see what those differences are. The increased income increases your taxes and the increase in withholding may not have kept up.

DawnC · ‎January 16, 2020