2381480
turbotax icon
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Announcements
Close icon
Do you have a TurboTax Online account?

We'll help you get started or pick up where you left off.

FROA
Level 1

My son is 21 years old and Full Time Student. Should I continue to claim him or is it better for him to file his own - for Financial Aid Purposes?

My son is 21 years old and Full Time Student. Should I continue to claim him or is it better for him to file his own - for Financial Aid Purposes?

x
Do you have an Intuit account?

Do you have an Intuit account?

You'll need to sign in or create an account to connect with an expert.

1 Best answer

Accepted Solutions

My son is 21 years old and Full Time Student. Should I continue to claim him or is it better for him to file his own - for Financial Aid Purposes?


@FROA wrote:

If I may rephrase -  can my son claim himself (I will not claim him) so that he can qualify for college tuition help from the federal and/or state?


Under the tax laws, if he qualifies to be claimed as a dependent, he must check the box that says "I can be claimed as a dependent by another taxpayer" even if he doesn't want to be claimed and even if you don't want to claim him.  

 

If he can be claimed, but is not claimed by you, he might be eligible for part of the American Opportunity Credit in his own name instead of you claiming it on your tax return.  But to get any part of the credit, he must have taxable income of more than $12,550.

 

If he could be claimed, but is not actually claimed by you, I don't know how that would affect his financial aid.  However, if he falsely answers "No-one else can claim me as a dependent" that could be considered tax fraud, as it would qualify him for a stimulus payment and possibly other tax benefits. 

 

 

For the rules, see here.

https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p501.pdf

 

There are two main ways that he would no longer qualify to be your dependent:

1. He provides more than half his own support.  Support he provides himself includes money he earns, as well as student loans taken out in his name.  Support that you provide includes the value of housing (if he lives at home over the summer), food, clothing, travel, medical insurance (if you provide it) and tuition (if you help pay).  If he provides more than half his own support, he can't be claimed as a dependent.  Some students, if they have a good side job and large loans in their own name, will put themselves over that 50.1% threshold. 

 

2.  He does not live more than half the year in your home.  College students are considered to "live at home" because being away at college is considered a temporary absence.  However, if he has definitely moved out and established an independent residence that he pays for, he might be considered to no longer "live at home."  There is no black-letter rule for this, it depends on the facts and circumstances. 

View solution in original post

6 Replies
Donna F 77
Employee Tax Expert

My son is 21 years old and Full Time Student. Should I continue to claim him or is it better for him to file his own - for Financial Aid Purposes?

IRS doesn't actually give you the option of claiming your child or passing the dependency to the child.  So, if you are actually providing over 50% of the child's support while he is 21 and a full time student, then you should be claiming the child.  If his income is much lower than yours (which I'm assuming it is), that would probably be more favorable for financial aid purposes.  However, if his income is too low to actually support himself, it may raise questions with the financial aid. 

**Say "Thanks" by clicking the thumb icon in a post
**Mark the post that answers your question by clicking on "Mark as Best Answer"
FROA
Level 1

My son is 21 years old and Full Time Student. Should I continue to claim him or is it better for him to file his own - for Financial Aid Purposes?

If I may rephrase -  can my son claim himself (I will not claim him) so that he can qualify for college tuition help from the federal and/or state?

My son is 21 years old and Full Time Student. Should I continue to claim him or is it better for him to file his own - for Financial Aid Purposes?


@FROA wrote:

If I may rephrase -  can my son claim himself (I will not claim him) so that he can qualify for college tuition help from the federal and/or state?


If your son can be claimed as a dependent even though he is not being claimed as a dependent on someone else's tax return then he must indicate on his tax return that he can be claimed as a dependent.

My son is 21 years old and Full Time Student. Should I continue to claim him or is it better for him to file his own - for Financial Aid Purposes?


@FROA wrote:

If I may rephrase -  can my son claim himself (I will not claim him) so that he can qualify for college tuition help from the federal and/or state?


Under the tax laws, if he qualifies to be claimed as a dependent, he must check the box that says "I can be claimed as a dependent by another taxpayer" even if he doesn't want to be claimed and even if you don't want to claim him.  

 

If he can be claimed, but is not claimed by you, he might be eligible for part of the American Opportunity Credit in his own name instead of you claiming it on your tax return.  But to get any part of the credit, he must have taxable income of more than $12,550.

 

If he could be claimed, but is not actually claimed by you, I don't know how that would affect his financial aid.  However, if he falsely answers "No-one else can claim me as a dependent" that could be considered tax fraud, as it would qualify him for a stimulus payment and possibly other tax benefits. 

 

 

For the rules, see here.

https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p501.pdf

 

There are two main ways that he would no longer qualify to be your dependent:

1. He provides more than half his own support.  Support he provides himself includes money he earns, as well as student loans taken out in his name.  Support that you provide includes the value of housing (if he lives at home over the summer), food, clothing, travel, medical insurance (if you provide it) and tuition (if you help pay).  If he provides more than half his own support, he can't be claimed as a dependent.  Some students, if they have a good side job and large loans in their own name, will put themselves over that 50.1% threshold. 

 

2.  He does not live more than half the year in your home.  College students are considered to "live at home" because being away at college is considered a temporary absence.  However, if he has definitely moved out and established an independent residence that he pays for, he might be considered to no longer "live at home."  There is no black-letter rule for this, it depends on the facts and circumstances. 

My son is 21 years old and Full Time Student. Should I continue to claim him or is it better for him to file his own - for Financial Aid Purposes?

Sorry if he is under 24 and a full time student he qualifies as your dependent.  If he qualify as someone’s dependent he needs to say on his return that he CAN be claimed even if they do not claim him on their return, See
https://ttlc.intuit.com/community/dependents/help/when-do-i-have-to-answer-yes-to-being-claimed-as-a...

FROA
Level 1

My son is 21 years old and Full Time Student. Should I continue to claim him or is it better for him to file his own - for Financial Aid Purposes?

Thank you very much!

Unlock tailored help options in your account.

message box icon

Get more help

Ask questions and learn more about your taxes and finances.

Post your Question