I just withdrew contributions from my ROTH IRA before the 5-year maturity requirement. Can I repay this back to my ROTH now to avoid paying the 10% penalty?

bldeviled — Tue, 24 Feb 2026 07:14:16 GMT

Re: I just withdrew contributions from my ROTH IRA before the 5-year maturity requirement. Can I repay this back to my ROTH now to avoid paying the 10% penalty?

NCperson — Fri, 29 Sep 2023 00:55:58 GMT

@bldeviled you may not need to depends on certain factors. However, you are permitted to return the money to the Roth within 60 days of the distribution and you can only do that once per year.

First, if you are over 59.5 years old, there is no 10% penalty. Period.

As your state the Roth (and that is ANY Roth you own) was open for less than 5 CALENDAR years (and assuming you are under 59.5 years old, the 10% penalty would only occur under the following circumstances:

The IRS assumes that dollars distributed from a Roth IRA follow this order

1) Original contributions - there is never 10% penalty on this bucket of money. Once this bucket is totally distributed, then

2) Conversion contributions are distributed - these are dollars that were converted from a Trad IRA. THere is a 10% penalty on these dollars that were disributed. Once this bucket is totall distributed, then

3) Earnings are distributed. There is a 10% penalty on these dollars.

While the rules are complex, the ones I stated in 1), 2) and 3) presume ANY Roth you own has been opened for less than five CALENDAR years and you are under 59.5 years old. The rules may differ under other permutations.

How old are you and what month / year did you open the Roth?

topic I just withdrew contributions from my ROTH IRA before the 5-year maturity requirement. Can I repay this back to my ROTH now to avoid paying the 10% penalty? in Retirement tax questions

I just withdrew contributions from my ROTH IRA before the 5-year maturity requirement. Can I repay this back to my ROTH now to avoid paying the 10% penalty?

Re: I just withdrew contributions from my ROTH IRA before the 5-year maturity requirement. Can I repay this back to my ROTH now to avoid paying the 10% penalty?