topic Re: QCD vs deduction in Deductions & credits

QCD vs deduction

OldCarGuy — Wed, 11 Feb 2026 05:40:06 GMT

I have QCD donations -- is it better (less tax) to list as a contribtuon or as QCD from retirement plan

Re: QCD vs deduction

Mike9241 — Wed, 20 Mar 2024 17:02:24 GMT

QCDs are not deductible as charitable contributions on Schedule A. But, as with deductible contributions, the donor must get a written acknowledgement of their contribution from the charitable organization before filing their return.

Re: QCD vs deduction

OldCarGuy — Wed, 20 Mar 2024 17:06:03 GMT

yes I have the letters and the QCD form from the bank -

- does a QCD donation reduce my income or treated like a normal contribtion

Re: QCD vs deduction

dmertz — Wed, 20 Mar 2024 20:45:36 GMT

For a distribution that satisfies the requirements to be eligible to be claimed as a QCD, I can't imagine any situation where deducting the contribution on Schedule A would be beneficial compared to claiming the distribution as a QCD, but I can imagine many situations where it would be detrimental to claim it on Schedule A instead of as a QCD.

Re: QCD vs deduction

Hal_Al — Wed, 20 Mar 2024 22:14:45 GMT

Q. Does a QCD donation reduce my income or treated like a normal charitable contribution (deducted on schedule A)?

A. It reduces your income.

But, you will not see a line item (a QCD amount) on any IRS form for the reduction (deduction). Look at lines 4a and 4b on form 1040. Line 4a will be the total amount of the distribution. Line 4b will be the reduced taxable amount. The notation "QCD" will appear on the dotted line between lines 4a & 4b. The difference between the two amounts will usually be the amount of the QCD. But, if your distribution also included portions of previous non-deductible contributions, that amount will also be in the difference.

Re: QCD vs deduction

OldCarGuy — Mon, 01 Apr 2024 15:51:29 GMT

thanks for the detailed reply -- i have no entries in the boxes you listed -- how do i enter these "gifts" as QCDs?

Re: QCD vs deduction

Hal_Al — Mon, 01 Apr 2024 16:22:35 GMT

Q. How do I enter these "gifts" as QCDs?

A. In the 1099-R interview. After entering the 1099-R, you will reach a screen, in the follow up interview, titled "Transfer to Charity". Check either the box that all of the distribution was transferred to charity or part of it. If only part, the next screen will ask you to enter the amount.

Re: QCD vs deduction

OldCarGuy — Mon, 01 Apr 2024 16:26:19 GMT

that worked -- thanks