topic Re: Income tax withheld in wrong state in State tax filing

Income tax withheld in wrong state

None2 — Thu, 06 Jun 2019 08:44:34 GMT

My spouse's employer withheld income tax in Virginia by mistake. We didn't pay attention and catch this. We do not live, work, own property, etc in Virginia. We live in a state with no state income tax. Based on searching, this is my understanding of how we recover the income.
1. Get the employer to stop.
2. File a Virginia non-resident return. Ensure that we clearly state that no income is associated with Virginia. Claim full amount as refund.

My questions:
1. Is this correct?
2. Some posts say that this should be filed in by mail with some supporting documents (Passport, Social Security). Is this better?

Yes, this is correct. For Virginia, this is the way you...

DanielV01 — Thu, 06 Jun 2019 08:44:36 GMT

Yes, this is correct. For Virginia, this is the way you can get the taxes back. You will need to send in a copy of the W-2, and then some statement that shows where your work location and your residence is so that they see that it is not Virginia income. For this, you can use VA Form 763-S, which you can find on this link: http://www.tax.virginia.gov/sites/default/files/taxforms/individual-income-tax/2016/763-s-2016.pdf. You will get the taxes back.

Mailing your return in will probably be the best option since if Virginia doesn't see the proof they will probably ask for it.

Re: Yes, this is correct. For Virginia, this is the way you...

nikittran — Fri, 07 Feb 2020 07:39:36 GMT

What is the equivalent form for CA. I work remotely from WA but my company is in CA. I was paying CA taxes from my paycheck but I do all my work in WA.

How can i request my tax withholding be returned to me?

Re: Yes, this is correct. For Virginia, this is the way you...

DianeC958 — Fri, 07 Feb 2020 15:25:15 GMT

You will need to file a non-resident California tax return showing that you have no income that is taxable to California.

If you want to efile your return put that you have $1 of taxable income and then you can efile if you put $0 as your income for California you will need to print, sign, date and mail the forms to California.

@nikittran

Re: Yes, this is correct. For Virginia, this is the way you...

Alangella — Sat, 28 Mar 2020 16:18:27 GMT

Please help with New Jersey.

I transferred from NJ to NYC in 2018. I am a NYC resident but my employer continued to withhold taxes for new jersey in 2019

Re: Yes, this is correct. For Virginia, this is the way you...

MaryK4 — Sat, 28 Mar 2020 20:06:30 GMT

Make sure that you had them change your tax withholding for 2020 or you will have the same issue next year. For 2019, you will have to file a New Jersey nonresident return and report no NJ income to get the withholding refunded. Then you most likely will have tax due to New York resident tax.

@Alangella

Re: Yes, this is correct. For Virginia, this is the way you...

Dan — Sat, 28 Mar 2020 20:40:36 GMT

I work construction for a company that sends me to work in multiple states. In 2019 I worked in Iowa, Missouri and Minnesota. My W2 incorrectly assigned my Iowa Income to Kansas. I called them and they said they would send me a corrected W2. That was many weeks ago and still have not received the corrected W2. I want to file now because I am getting money back. What are my options?

Re: Yes, this is correct. For Virginia, this is the way you...

ThomasM125 — Sun, 29 Mar 2020 23:13:25 GMT

You can file the return using the W-2 you have and then file an amended return to correct it when you get the corrected W-2 form.

Re: Yes, this is correct. For Virginia, this is the way you...

JasonTryharder — Tue, 19 May 2020 03:13:31 GMT

Can you help with Michigan tax withholdings, I work in Michigan, but my address is in Ohio, I have 9 months of withholding in MI, and asked my employer to change to ohio after I found out.

Since MI and OH are reciprocal state, one who lives in one state and work in another can only pay to one state.

and I am full year resident to OH, so I think of my action would be :

1 file for full refund for MI withholdings

2 pay for OH tax

Can you tell how should I do it ?

Many thanks

Re: Yes, this is correct. For Virginia, this is the way you...

TomD8 — Tue, 19 May 2020 15:38:35 GMT

@JasonTryharder :

1) file a non-resident MI tax return, showing zero MI income, in order to obtain a refund of the incorrectly withheld MI taxes.

2) file your resident OH return. ALL your income is taxable by OH.

Re: Income tax withheld in wrong state

dval29 — Mon, 15 Feb 2021 19:04:10 GMT

Hello -

This is similar to my situation, but is there any way to get the mistakenly withheld money back sooner?

My situation:

- I live and work from Florida

- My employer mistakenly had CT marked on my first paycheck of 2021 (Jan 15, 2021), so $500 was withheld by the state of CT

- I caught it immediately and my employer has fixed it for all future paychecks

- It is now Feb of 2021, how do I get the $500 back from last month? Do I have to wait 1+ years to file a 2021 return with CT? That seems unfair. They have my money. I would like it back.

Thank you!

Re: Income tax withheld in wrong state

JotikaT2 — Mon, 15 Feb 2021 19:24:24 GMT

You cannot do this on your end yet.

Your employer would need to make the correction on their end. Typically employers have a quarterly filing requirement for payroll. Therefore, their first CR-941 Payroll report would not be due until the end of the first quarter of 2021.

I recommend contacting your employer to ask that they make the correction on their end as they have not filed any returns yet. They may be able to reconcile it now so you do not have to wait until the next tax filing year to refund your withholdings.

CT withholding taxes by employers

Re: Income tax withheld in wrong state

dval29 — Mon, 01 Mar 2021 21:21:23 GMT

Hi @JotikaT2 Thank you for the response.

My employer is telling me that they cannot return the money to me. This is what they said:

"For the size employer we are, we are on bi-weekly CT withholding remittance for withholdings, unemployment insurance is quarterly. We can do a payroll journal correction but that doesn't get you your money back that just changes whats on paper for us."

So does this mean I must wait until 2022 to get my money back, even though I caught it within weeks? Thanks

Re: Income tax withheld in wrong state

JotikaT2 — Mon, 01 Mar 2021 21:29:09 GMT

Yes, you will need to wait until you receive your W-2 form for the 2021 income tax year and file a nonresident tax return for CT. You will see the CT withholdings in the state section of your W-2 form.

Re: Income tax withheld in wrong state

cdail — Mon, 15 Mar 2021 20:51:05 GMT

I had a similar issue. I started a new job in Texas and moved from Arkansas. My employer had my Arkansas address on file for my first 3 paychecks so I had state income taxes taken out when I was living in Texas. What form would I fill out to get that amount back? I searched online for "nonresident claim for individual income tax withheld" and nothing showed.

Re: Income tax withheld in wrong state

JotikaT2 — Mon, 15 Mar 2021 21:07:24 GMT

If your employer will not correct the issue on their end, you would need to file a Nonresident and Part Year Resident AR1000NR, Arkansas Individual Income Tax Return to get a refund of your income taxes withheld.

Arkansas nonresident form

When using TurboTax to prepare you nonresident wages, you would need to indicate that none of the wages were applicable to Arkansas in the state interview section. This will result in your state tax return showing no taxable income and allow you to get a refund for all of your state income taxes withheld erroneously by your employer.

Re: Income tax withheld in wrong state

Dan — Mon, 15 Mar 2021 23:02:23 GMT

I would start by asking your employer for a corrected W2 that moves that withholding to Texas. Otherwise I believe you will need to file an Arkansas tax return to get that money back.

Re: Income tax withheld in wrong state

DawnC — Mon, 15 Mar 2021 23:19:33 GMT

Texas does not have a state income tax so there are no withholdings for that state. A nonresident return for Arkansas would need to be filed to collect the erroneous withholdings.

Re: Income tax withheld in wrong state

krhusbands — Sun, 16 Jan 2022 16:20:17 GMT

Hi,

How can I do the same but for income taxes withheld in NY?

I live in TX and was taxed in NY in Feb 2021. My employer says they can't correct anything on their end because they claim its my fault the address wasn't updated.

Thanks for any help.

Re: Income tax withheld in wrong state

TomD8 — Sun, 16 Jan 2022 17:10:51 GMT

@krhusbands --

If you're sure the withholding was incorrect (you neither lived in nor worked in NY at that time), then in order to obtain a refund you would have to file a NY non-resident return, showing the withholding and allocating zero income to NY.