topic Apparent computation error -- NY State in Get your taxes done using TurboTax

Apparent computation error -- NY State

wrdbrn — Tue, 24 Feb 2026 05:24:03 GMT

I hate to do this, but . . . Turbotax accurately computes our NY State taxes according to the NY State Tax Rate Schedule on page 43 of the IT201 instructions. However, the numbers on our return put us into Tax computation worksheet 3 on page 46. According to worksheet 3, we would owe $3,016 more in NY State tax (conincidentally the same amount as the Recapture Base Amount line on Tax computation worksheet 4, same page). My question is should we pay the higher or lower amount, and what are the consequences if we pay either too little or too much? Thanks for your help!

Re: Apparent computation error -- NY State

AmyC — Thu, 13 Apr 2023 22:22:40 GMT

It will be your choice.

Paying too little:

Interest and penalties - Tax.NY.gov.
TurboTax does have an accuracy guarantee. How to submit documentation for accuracy guarantee claims

Paying too much:

The state will show an overage and either keep it to apply in the future or send you a check.

Re: Apparent computation error -- NY State

wrdbrn — Mon, 17 Apr 2023 12:05:38 GMT

Actually, it turns out that a math challenged individual needs to run the New York numbers three or four times, and then they agree with turbotax's calculations. So, all good. And thanks for the reply