turbotax icon
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Announcements
Close icon
Do you have a TurboTax Online account?

We'll help you get started or pick up where you left off.

colaivf
New Member

When I add my Roth IRA, I'm told I contributed too much because "earned income was only zero." My W2 form shows income is definitely not zero. How to fix on TurboTax?

I contributed $5,500 to my Roth IRA.

My earned income is close to $20,000

Why is TurboTax calculating my earned income as zero on the Roth contribution page?

How can I fix this?

Please see attached screenshots.

x
Do you have an Intuit account?

Do you have an Intuit account?

You'll need to sign in or create an account to connect with an expert.

1 Best answer

Accepted Solutions

When I add my Roth IRA, I'm told I contributed too much because "earned income was only zero." My W2 form shows income is definitely not zero. How to fix on TurboTax?

Glad I could help.  Thanks for posting back.

View solution in original post

14 Replies
maglib
Level 10

When I add my Roth IRA, I'm told I contributed too much because "earned income was only zero." My W2 form shows income is definitely not zero. How to fix on TurboTax?

[removed]
**I don't work for TT. Just trying to help. All the best.
***Say "Thanks" by marking as BEST ANSWER and clicking the thumb icon in a post and that I solved your question
**Mark the post that answers your question by clicking on "Mark as Best Answer"
I am NOT an expert and you should confirm with a tax expert.
Carl
Level 15

When I add my Roth IRA, I'm told I contributed too much because "earned income was only zero." My W2 form shows income is definitely not zero. How to fix on TurboTax?

@maglib look at the screenshot again. It shows W-2 income, and the self-employment section hasn't been entered into yet. My guess is, they're filing a joint return and incorrectly identified the W-2 as belonging to their spouse. So as far as the program is concerned, the poster of this thread has no income at all.

When I add my Roth IRA, I'm told I contributed too much because "earned income was only zero." My W2 form shows income is definitely not zero. How to fix on TurboTax?

Yes be sure both the W2 and IRA contribution are assigned to the same person.
colaivf
New Member

When I add my Roth IRA, I'm told I contributed too much because "earned income was only zero." My W2 form shows income is definitely not zero. How to fix on TurboTax?

I'm filing as single

When I add my Roth IRA, I'm told I contributed too much because "earned income was only zero." My W2 form shows income is definitely not zero. How to fix on TurboTax?

"Earned income" is income subject to social security tax (FICA and/or self-employment tax).  Are you exempt from social security for some reason (clergy, etc.)?
colaivf
New Member

When I add my Roth IRA, I'm told I contributed too much because "earned income was only zero." My W2 form shows income is definitely not zero. How to fix on TurboTax?

@Carl, @maglib & @VolvoGirl , - feels like a program error, - where do I turn for help?
colaivf
New Member

When I add my Roth IRA, I'm told I contributed too much because "earned income was only zero." My W2 form shows income is definitely not zero. How to fix on TurboTax?

@Opus 17 - not exempt from social security

When I add my Roth IRA, I'm told I contributed too much because "earned income was only zero." My W2 form shows income is definitely not zero. How to fix on TurboTax?

Do you have any other kind of income?  Like Foreign income?
colaivf
New Member

When I add my Roth IRA, I'm told I contributed too much because "earned income was only zero." My W2 form shows income is definitely not zero. How to fix on TurboTax?

@VolvoGirl  - No other income

When I add my Roth IRA, I'm told I contributed too much because "earned income was only zero." My W2 form shows income is definitely not zero. How to fix on TurboTax?

Try deleting the W2 and re-enter it.  That may clear something out.

When I add my Roth IRA, I'm told I contributed too much because "earned income was only zero." My W2 form shows income is definitely not zero. How to fix on TurboTax?

It's hard to trouble shoot the online version because you can't print the forms or worksheets until after you pay the fee, or after you file if you are using the free version, and free version users aren't entitled to phone support.  You could upgrade to the Plus version and then try and call support, they can do a screen share and look at the details of your file to see where the error is.  Maybe you entered box 3 of your W-2 incorrectly.  If self-employed, you might be showing a loss due to errors in the data entry.  We can't rule out a bug, either, although your problem has not been commonly reported recently.

When I add my Roth IRA, I'm told I contributed too much because "earned income was only zero." My W2 form shows income is definitely not zero. How to fix on TurboTax?

If previously married and now filing single, your spouse is still built into the program.  It is recommended that you abandon this return and open a new account with a new user name and password.  It's difficult to eradicate a spouse from an existing account.
colaivf
New Member

When I add my Roth IRA, I'm told I contributed too much because "earned income was only zero." My W2 form shows income is definitely not zero. How to fix on TurboTax?

Well done @VolvoGirl! I deleted W2 and reentered it, - everything fixed itself! Thank you everyone else for their ideas and help!

When I add my Roth IRA, I'm told I contributed too much because "earned income was only zero." My W2 form shows income is definitely not zero. How to fix on TurboTax?

Glad I could help.  Thanks for posting back.

Unlock tailored help options in your account.

message box icon

Get more help

Ask questions and learn more about your taxes and finances.

Post your Question