Announcements
Ask the Experts about the Child Tax Credit >> Event happening NOW!
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Scouture
Level 1

Credit Card Settlement Dilemma

I have an old credit card debt that is due to "fall off my credit report" in Dec 2021.

They have sent me a settlement agreement that I need to respond to in the next 30 days. I can afford the settlement that they are offering, but am afraid of how it will impact my taxes this year. I believe that the remaining unpaid balance will be considered "income" and negatively impact my taxes.

I have 2 questions really:

  • Is there a difference between a "Satisfied Settlement" and "Charge Off" in regards to my credit score?
  • Is it best to pay the settlement agreement or do nothing and let it fall off my report?

Thanks for your help & input.

1 Best answer

Accepted Solutions
tagteam
Level 15

Credit Card Settlement Dilemma

Another user will likely chime in with a response, but you should be made aware that merely because the debt "falls off your credit report" does not necessarily indicate that you will not be receiving a tax reporting statement (i.e., a 1099-C) showing the debt as having been cancelled by the creditor. In that event, you will most likely have to report the entire amount of the debt as income.

View solution in original post

3 Replies
tagteam
Level 15

Credit Card Settlement Dilemma

Another user will likely chime in with a response, but you should be made aware that merely because the debt "falls off your credit report" does not necessarily indicate that you will not be receiving a tax reporting statement (i.e., a 1099-C) showing the debt as having been cancelled by the creditor. In that event, you will most likely have to report the entire amount of the debt as income.

View solution in original post

reallymeamom
Level 1

Credit Card Settlement Dilemma

If you send the creditor any money or even correspond it automatically reinstates the debt as current and could be another several years before it goes off your credit report.  This is a tactic often used by collection agencies. The original debt has been charged off already, and that is what affects your credit regardless because that debt is considered closed by whomever you defaulted the debt with originally and that status doesn't change.  The collection companies buy the debt for pennies on the dollar...in the hopes of collecting more than they paid for your debt.  If the statute of limitations for collecting the debt has run out, then they cannot sue you.  However.,THEY WILL NOT ADVISE YOU OF THIS!!!  It is very important that you research what is legal for your situation.  Debt collection agencies are notoriously unscrupulous and in the business of collecting money by whatever means necessary. (Even from my widowed 80 year old father)   If they get you to verbally acknowledge the debt or collect even 1 cent...It's a brand new debt and they can sue you because it is now a brand new account that you've already defaulted on.  If it's within the statute if limitations and they have bank account info/access to any bank accounts you've previously used to pay  they will just get a judgement an put a collection lien on your account...usually with the minimum of notice to you.  If you've already gotten hooked by them, change your bank accounts and offer them pennies on the dollar. It's all negotiable, play hard ball.  Depending on the amount of debt, sometimes court fees aren't worth it to them and they will settle.

reallymeamom
Level 1

Credit Card Settlement Dilemma

Re: Taxes, the charged off income will need to be reported on your taxes.

Privacy Settings
v