Wages form w2 - Should Box 16 have $0 and Box 17 still have the withholding if no work was conducted in that state, but tax was withheld?

Forum|Forum|7 years ago
June 6, 2019
7 replies
46 views

Ex. Total Fed. Income earned $10,000, State of employment has $10,000 in Box 16 and has withholding. A second W2 was issued for State of residence with $7,000 in Box 16 and has withholding. No work was conducted in the State of residence, but tax was withheld. Should Box 16 have $0 for Box 16 and still have the withholding in Box 17?

TurboTax Deluxe Windows

DanielV01

Level 15

It depends, but it's probably correct. Both states likely tax you. (But please comment the two states so that we can give further clarification: there may be special circumstances). Your resident state taxes all of your income regardless of where you earned it. Your nonresident state taxes income earned in the state. Your resident state will give you a credit for the amount of tax you must pay to your nonresident state on that double-taxed income, but if the nonresident state has a much lower tax rate than your resident state, then the amount of the tax credit will not cover your resident state's tax liability, and the additional withholding will cover the shortfall.

Having said this, please feel free to comment the states, because there's probably additional detail that I can provide you with that information.

**Say "Thanks" by clicking the thumb icon in a post. **Mark the post that answers your question by clicking on "Mark as Best Answer"

ehann5Author

Level 2

All work the total $10,000 was conducted in CT. MA tax was withheld in addition to CT so that estimated taxes didn't have to be paid to MA (state of residence). I am aware that both states will tax, but the way the W2s are displayed, TurboTax has it showing $17,000 of income for MA.

xxxxyyyzzz23

Level 2

Hi I have a similar situation. I have worked in california and received two w2 forms from my employer one for CA state and other for MA state which is my resident state. I have fed income and tax mentioned in my CA w2 form and CA wages in box 16 of the same w2.However I have not earned any wages in MA but I was taxed for being a resident. in my MA w2 box 1 and 2 are empty , but box 16 has the wages mentioned for which I was being taxed by MA and I have my taxes mentioned in box 17. when I file my taxes using turbo tax for MA state , the software adds up the income from box 16 , and my total wages show more wages then what have actually earned.I am facing trouble filing my MA return. please help how can I sort this issue out