Skip to main content
Level 2
Feb 16, 2023 7:19 AM UTC
Question

Roth IRA excess withdrawal issue - I read everything posted but still have an issue ---

I appreciate any help---

I did make an excess contribution of $7000 to my Roth IRA in January 2021 by mistake...

At the end of December 2021 I did transfer my Roth IRA to another firm (this is somewahat irrelevant perhaps)

When I filed my taxes in April 2022 I did pay $420 penalty for this excess contribution.

 

Now in November 2022 I withdraw $7000  from Roth-IRA.

I was thinking that now I removed the excess, everything is fine, this $7000 would be subject to an ordinary 

income tax.

 

However, Turbo Tax asks me which is year shown on 1099R, which is 2022 on mine...then it tells me I have to amend 2021 return, shows a tax of $840. Why should I amend anything?

 

If I select the year 2023 then the tax it shows is zero. However my 1099R shows year 2022.

Please help!

 

Mitch.

 

 

 

    4 replies

    Level 2
    Feb 16, 2023 7:46 AM UTC

    I forgot to say that my 1099R form shows the code

    P - Excess contributions plus earnings/excess deferrals (and/or earnings) taxable in 2021.

    Thank you for any help!

    Alumni - Intuit
    Feb 16, 2023 11:13 PM UTC

    You are paying tax on the income earned in the ROTH IRA and it belongs in 2021, since that is when the funds were contributed. You paid a penalty tax on the excess contribution on your 2021 tax return, but you haven't paid tax on the income earned yet, so you need to amend the 2021 return to report the earnings reported in box 2(a) on your 1099-R form.

     

     

    **Say "Thanks" by clicking the thumb icon in a post. **Mark the post that answers your question by clicking on "Mark as Best Answer"
    Level 2
    Feb 17, 2023 5:54 AM UTC

    Hi ThomasM125,

     

    thank you for the answer, but

    I paid the penalty and removed the excess after Oct 15 deadline. As far as I understand

    the earnings are not involved anymore.  Besides my 1099R box 2 is empty.

     

    There is this statement from MotleyFool (and I have seen the same thing in many other places:)

    "Another option for those who didn't correct their mistake before the tax deadline in the year they made an excess contribution is to withdraw it next year. If you do this, you have to take out only the contribution, not any earnings. You'll pay the 6% excise tax for the year you left the excess contribution in your account, but you won't have to worry about this tax in future years."

     

    and this is what I did actually.  

     

    Thank you for any feedback!