Sorry this is a bit confusing. I tried to follow the IRS instructions and got...

Line 52 = $5986 (calculated RMD)

Line 53 = $0 or $5986? (no distribution was made in 2019, it was discovered and taken in 2020..I'm guessing $0)

Line 54 = assuming "$0" on Line 53 then = $5986 on line with "RC (5986)" to the left of the Line 54 box.

Line 55 = $2993 (penalty amount).....but do I actually include the payment with my mailed in taxes or not?

Line 55 will be zero because you are requesting waiver on the entire amount.

The 5329 should look like this:

@ender 

Yes you followed the instructions in Form 5329.

Every year I send comment to  IRS requesting to clarify the instructions.

However, according to the esteemed IRA experts on the forum macuser_22 and dmertz, you are misreading it.

Do it their way because it seems to always work, and you don't have to send in any money.

---

@fanfare wrote:

@ender 

Yes you followed the instructions in Form 5329.

Every year I send comment to  IRS requesting to clarify the instructions.

 

However, according to the esteemed IRA experts on the forum

macuser_22 and dmertz, you are misreading it.

Do it their way because it seems to always work, and you don't have to send in any money.

---

I am not "misreading it".   The screenshot I posted is how TurboTax does it and  is exactally as the IRS 5329 instructions say to enter it:

Quote:

1. Complete lines 52 and 53 as
instructed.
2. Enter “RC” and the amount of the
shortfall you want waived in
parentheses on the dotted line next to
line 54. Subtract this amount from the
total shortfall you figured without regard
to the waiver, and enter the result on
line 54.

The "amount of the shortfall you want waived"  is (obviously) the amount of the RMD that was missed from line 52.  When that amount is subtracted from itself, the result is zero, which goes on line 54.   Line 55 is 50% of zero on line 54 that can only be zero on line 55.

What part of the IRS instructions do you not understand?

@macuser_22 

OK macuser_22

I did not say you are misreading it.
I said you are telling the OP that he misread it.

Well what do you know -- IRS has changed the wording in the instructions for 2019 Form 5329.

We've had this discussion many times before in earlier years. I had conceded then and I concede now..

@macuser_22    cc:  @dmertz 

P.S.

You should update your original boilerplate answer. In Step 2, you are quoting the old instruction, not the 2019 instruction.

---

@fanfare wrote:

@macuser_22    cc:  @dmertz 

P.S.

You should update your original boilerplate answer. In Step 2, you are quoting the old instruction, not the 2019 instruction.

---

I fail to see any material difference between my "boilerplate":

2. Enter “RC” and the amount you want waived in parentheses on the dotted line next to line 54. Subtract this amount from the total shortfall you figured without regard to the waiver, and enter the result on line 54.

and the current:

2. Enter “RC” and the amount of the
shortfall you want waived in
parentheses on the dotted line next to
line 54. Subtract this amount from the
total shortfall you figured without regard
to the waiver, and enter the result on
line 54.

Looks about the same to me.

@macuser_22 

Well there's a big difference, and that should be clear to anyone. This discussion is going nowhere.

---

@fanfare wrote:

@macuser_22 

 

Well there's a big difference, and that should be clear to anyone. This discussion is going nowhere.

---

I don't see any material difference, but I will add "amount of shortfall" to my answer- just to be current.   Thanks for pointing that out.

Also, the last paragraph of that section now indicates that the IRS will provide explicit notice as to whether they deny or grant the waiver.  In the past they didn't always provide notice when they granted the waiver.

Great thanks for the clarification! My advisor took the RMD's, but I don't have any 1099-R for 2019 from TD Ameritrade nor do I think I will receive any as far as I can tell since they were taken late in 2020 to rectify the mistake. I am using the online version - so I will need to print it out and file the form with the letter of explanation with it. I am assuming that in the end where you finalize everything there is an option to "print and mail" rather than e-file. Assuming this....where does Form 5329 and statement of explanation go in the the huge stack of tax papers? Very front? Very back? I want them to SEE it or put it in its proper place. I couldn't really find any information on this.

@dmertz 

2019 Instructions for Form 5329
"If your request is not granted, the IRS will notify you
regarding any additional tax you may owe on the shortfall."

the phrase you cited "deny or grant" does not appear.

@ender Refer to IRS booklet  2019 1040 and 1040-SR Instructions for how to assemble your tax return.

From the instructions for Form 1040:

If you have supporting statements, arrange them in the same order as the schedules or forms they support and attach them last.