I am using 2023 TT desktop and trying to do scenario planning for 2024. I realize that isn't perfect, but should be close enough for what I'm doing. I am planning a 401k conversion to a Roth IRA in late 2024 and trying to understand the tax ramifications. I understand that a 401k conversion to Roth is taxed at my marginal tax rate, but am having difficulty understanding the actual calculation steps.
My income is in Dividends (mostly qualified) and Capital Gains. I first do a scenario with no conversion, and then one with a $30k conversion, so that I can compare the impact. To examine the tax calculation, I am going to the Qual Dividends and Capital Gains Tax Worksheet in TT.
All looks fine in the first scenario, without the conversion. When I add the conversion on a 1099R, TT appropriately adds the $30k to Taxable Income as I expect. On the Qual Div and Capital Gains tax worksheet, TT then subtracts $89250 (MFJ tax bracket for Cap Gains) from Taxable Income and multiplies by 15% (lines 17-18). Thus, the $30K conversion is being implicitly taxed at 15% since it isn't excluded from Taxable Income in this step. TT then does another tax table calculation for any non-Qual dividends + $30k conversion less Itemized Deductions. The tax table rate is about 11% blended. Thus, the conversion is taxed twice, once at 15% and then again via tax table. The outcome is my conversion is taxed and the marginal rate when I compare the 2 scenarios is about 26% which is not what my marginal rate should be.
Can you help me with the calculation logic?
You'll need to sign in or create an account to connect with an expert.
I think you are misreading the worksheet. The worksheet is ONLY taxing the capital gains and dividends.
However, you are correct that it could effectively be a very high tax rate. While the Roth conversion would be taxed at your regular tax rate, that 'extra' income could cause your capital gains/dividends to go from the 0% tax bracket up to the 15% tax bracket. That means the direct tax on the Roth conversion PLUS pushing your other income from 0% to 15% could effectively result in a very high tax outcome.
I think you are misreading the worksheet. The worksheet is ONLY taxing the capital gains and dividends.
However, you are correct that it could effectively be a very high tax rate. While the Roth conversion would be taxed at your regular tax rate, that 'extra' income could cause your capital gains/dividends to go from the 0% tax bracket up to the 15% tax bracket. That means the direct tax on the Roth conversion PLUS pushing your other income from 0% to 15% could effectively result in a very high tax outcome.
Still have questions?
Make a postAsk questions and learn more about your taxes and finances.
psychopengy
Level 1
moncul
Level 2
psychopengy
Level 1
pwarkentin
Level 2
thegoodreturn
Returning Member
Did the information on this page answer your question?
You have clicked a link to a site outside of the TurboTax Community. By clicking "Continue", you will leave the Community and be taken to that site instead.